Free Vs Machines.

Every lifter, coach, and gym-goer has asked it at some point.
Most answers come from biases.
Few look at the actual data and give a real answer.

So today, we’re dropping opinions and sticking to what the research says about strength and hypertrophy when comparing free weights and machines.

Let’s get into it.

A major trend appears across studies:
Strength increases are mostly specific to what you train on.

Here’s what repeated meta-analyses found:
-Test strength with a barbell lift: the barbell group wins.
-Test strength with a machine lift: the machine group wins.
-Test strength with a neutral tool (no bias): the results are similar.

A few studies reinforce this:
-8-10 week trials show similar overall strength gains when volume is matched.
-The only meaningful difference is test specificity. You get strongest at the thing you practice.

Clear takeaway:
Free weights don’t automatically produce more strength.
Machines don’t underperform.
Strength is mostly a product of training specificity with similar results overall.

This one surprises people.
Across multiple meta-analyses, when sets, reps, load, and effort are matched:
Free weights and machines produce equal hypertrophy.

Studies on arms, chest, legs, and full-body programs all show the same thing:

Same volume
Same intensity
Same proximity to failure
=
Same muscle growth, regardless of equipment.

Clear takeaway:
Muscle growth is driven by volume, effort, and progression.
Not whether the load comes from a barbell or a machine.

This is where people tend to assume free weights win.
And they’re partially right… but not in the way most think.

Here’s what EMG (muscle activation) studies show:
-Free weights often create higher activation in stabilizers like core, delts, and hips.
-Machines reduce stability demands and allow more focus on prime movers.
-Prime mover activation (chest, quads, etc.) is often similar between both.

What this means:
-Free weights challenge more muscles at once.
-Machines let you drive a targeted muscle through a fixed path.

But in actual outcomes (strength and hypertrophy), both still perform similarly when workload is matched.

-Free weights: better at free-weight tests.
-Machines: better at machine tests.
-Neutral Tests: similar gains.

-When effort and volume are equal, growth is equal.

-Free weights challenge stabilizers more.
-Machines remove stability demands but don’t reduce prime mover stimulus.

For strength and hypertrophy, free weights and machines are both highly effective.
The biggest differences come from how you train, not what you train with.

Both work.
Use the one that fits your goals, your structure, your equipment, and your phase of training.

Ready for structure, accountability, and real results?
Join a Squad and start training with a structured plan, real coaching, a community discord, and more⬇️

Or reply to this newsletter with any questions!

Thanks for reading this week’s edition of The Weekly Standard!

If you found value in these insights, share it with a training buddy or post it on your social feed; let’s spread the knowledge and push each other to new levels. See you next time!